Selected Stories of Anton Chekhov – Modern Library Classics – Book Review

Post Category: Short Stories
Selected Short Stories of Anton Chekhov book review

Anton Chekhov, often hailed as the master of the short story, occupies an unparalleled position in the realm of literature with his unparalleled ability to capture the nuances of human existence. His narratives, like delicate brushstrokes on the canvas of life, intricately depict the complexities of the human condition. Chekhov’s genius lies in his ability to seamlessly blend humour and pathos, offering readers profound insights into the subtle intricacies of relationships and the ever-shifting landscapes of the human psyche. As we delve into the timeless collection of his best short stories, we embark on a literary journey guided by Chekhov’s keen observations and unparalleled storytelling prowess, discovering a world where the ordinary becomes extraordinary and the mundane transforms into moments of profound revelation.

About the Book:

“Selected Stories of Anton Chekhov” stands as a literary treasure trove, encapsulating the essence of Chekhov’s mastery in the short story form. This collection, comprising 30 captivating tales, has been thoughtfully curated and translated into English by the acclaimed duo of Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky. As the foremost translators of Russian literature, Pevear and Volokhonsky bring to life Chekhov’s nuanced narratives, allowing English-speaking readers to savour the richness and depth of the original prose. Within the 496 pages of this Modern Library Classics edition, readers are invited to explore the timeless themes of love, human nature, and the intricacies of relationships, all skilfully woven into Chekhov’s brilliant storytelling. It’s not merely a collection of stories; it’s an invitation to immerse oneself in the unparalleled world of Chekhovian literature, made accessible and vibrant through the careful hands of exceptional translators.

A few words about the stories:

What can one say about the shot stories by Chekhov? You just read them, appreciate and drown yourself wilfully in the ocean of emotions – pathos – that the Russian master creates. Let’s discuss two stories, In Exile and Ward No. 6. To begin with, “In Exile” and “Ward No. 6” stand as towering pillars of Anton Chekhov’s literary prowess, showcasing his unmatched ability to dissect the complexities of the human condition. In “In Exile,” Chekhov explores the theme of displacement, delving into the psychological and emotional landscapes of characters forced to confront the challenges of life in unfamiliar territories. The narrative unfolds with a delicate touch, revealing the intricacies of human resilience and vulnerability.

On the other hand, “Ward No. 6” ventures into the realm of mental health, offering a poignant exploration of the human mind within the confines of an asylum. Through the interactions and experiences of the characters within Ward No. 6, Chekhov masterfully unveils the thin line between sanity and madness, challenging societal perceptions and provoking contemplation on the nature of institutionalisation.

Both stories exemplify Chekhov’s ability to weave profound narratives that resonate beyond their temporal and cultural contexts, inviting readers to reflect on the universal aspects of the human experience. With keen observations and a compassionate lens, Chekhov invites us to peer into the souls of his characters, creating stories that endure as timeless reflections on the complexities of existence.

Then there is The Darling. Olenka’s identity is fluid, adapting to the personalities of the men she associates with, be it her husband, a zoologist, a playwright, or a timber merchant. Chekhov skilfully dissects the complexities of Olenka’s character, revealing the profound impact external influences can have on one’s sense of self. Through Olenka’s journey, Chekhov delves into the themes of dependence, the search for meaning, and the consequences of losing oneself in the identities of others. The story unfolds with Chekhov’s trademark blend of humour and melancholy, offering a nuanced portrayal of human relationships and the quest for individuality.

Who can forget a masterpiece like Vanka? “Vanka” showcases Chekhov’s ability to infuse empathy and social commentary into his narratives, shedding light on the struggles of the marginalised. The story leaves a lasting impression as it invites readers to reflect on the universal themes of longing, loss, and the enduring spirit of hope in the face of adversity.

There are stories like Peasant Women, A Boring Story, A Medical Case and many others… appreciated by readers and critics alike… for centuries. Readers, you are in for a delightful and enriching experience that is often the byproduct of reading classic literature.


Let’s do the unthinkable – Critical Appreciation of Anton Chekhov as a short story writer:

Let’s begin with the obvious. Anton Chekhov stands as an icon in the realm of literature. His stories, characterised by subtlety, nuance, and a keen observation of human nature, have left an indelible mark on the literary landscape. Chekhov’s ability to capture the complexities of the human psyche and depict the minutiae of everyday life elevates his short stories to a level of profound realism. His exploration of the mundane and ordinary moments, often devoid of overt drama, highlights the beauty found in simplicity.

Chekhov’s narratives excel in portraying the universal aspects of the human condition, transcending cultural and temporal boundaries. His characters are not mere caricatures but multifaceted individuals grappling with the intricacies of existence. The economy of his prose, coupled with a deep understanding of human emotions, allows readers to connect with the characters on a visceral level. The brevity of his stories is, in itself, a testament to Chekhov’s skill in distilling the essence of life into compact and impactful narratives.

However, like any literary figure, Chekhov is not without his critics. Some argue that his penchant for ambiguity and open-ended conclusions can be frustrating for readers seeking more definitive resolutions. Additionally, his focus on the ordinary might be perceived as a limitation, with critics contending that it lacks the grandiosity associated with other forms of storytelling. Yet, these supposed shortcomings are often overshadowed by the overwhelming praise for Chekhov’s ability to capture the nuances of the human experience. And not to forget, these are purely subjective perceptions. However, about the author’s overambitious attempts to keep his stories open-ended, one can (and they do) argue – did he not find the perfect resolutions? What do you think, fellow reader?

Prominent literary figures, including contemporaries like Leo Tolstoy and later critics such as Vladimir Nabokov, have lauded Chekhov’s contributions to the short story genre. Tolstoy commended Chekhov’s ability to convey “the feeling of the characters,” recognising the profound impact of his stories on readers’ empathetic engagement. Nabokov, while acknowledging Chekhov’s focus on the commonplace, praised the author for transforming the seemingly mundane into something extraordinary through his nuanced storytelling.

In conclusion, Anton Chekhov’s legacy as a short story writer is marked by his unparalleled ability to distil the complexities of life into concise and impactful narratives. While some may critique his inclination towards ambiguity and the ordinary, his profound insights into the human condition continue to resonate across generations. Chekhov’s influence extends beyond his contemporaries, with literary figures recognising the enduring power of his short stories to illuminate the intricacies of our shared humanity.


CLICK HERE to get a copy of the Book – Selected Stories of Anton Chekhov – Amazon India 


Review and Commentary by Ashish for Indian Book Critics

Selected Stories of Anton Chekhov – Modern Library Classics – Book Review
  • Critical Rating


Unmissable! Emotional. Sometimes frustrating. Enjoyable. Must-read!

Explore More Posts:

1 Comment. Leave new

  • Shilpa Parihar
    December 7, 2023 3:46 am

    Thanks for this amazingly written review… I liked the way you did not leave the opportunity for someone to say you love Chekhov blindly… and, largely, agreeing you love Chekhov! haha getting a copy of the book right away!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.